COMBS-COOMBS &c.
INTERNATIONAL DNA STUDY

LINEAGES CONFIRMED BY DNA


[ TONOLOWAYS SETTLEMENT | STAFFORD CO, VA | ST. MARY’S CO, MD; JEFFERSON CO, TN; WILKES & COBB COS, GA | MIDDLESEX CO, NJ; CLAY CO, IN; SULLIVAN CO, TN | NEW MEADOWS, ME ]



As DNA matches occur there will be information that appears here clarifying the findings. The interpretations of these findings may change as more test results are added to the study. Five Colonial period Combs-Coombs &c. lineages have been confirmed linking hundreds of descendants with their shared ancestry. These lineages are outlined in the table below. This table does not include additonal Combs-Coombs &c. who have tested and are seeking DNA matches.

LINEAGE GENETIC PROFILE ESTABLISHEDMATCHEXTENT OF MATCH*COMMENTS
AMERICA
“Tonoloways Settlement” Pennsylvania Colony/Maryland Colony Combs
Joseph COOMBS Descendants CONCLUSION:

So far “4” main branches share the same ancestry.
See Special Study: TONOLOWAYS SETTLEMENT Pennsylvania Maryland ~ mid 1700s Lineage

NEXT RESEARCH STEP:

The group as a whole needs to examine the possibility of a migration to the Tonoloways from the Massachusetts - Maine - New Jersey direction since there is evidence of a close match by a surname involved with the Primitive Baptists, some of which turned up in the Tonoloways Settlement from New Jersey. The name COOMBS is also more common as a spelling in the New England area than other areas of the country.
See the Special Study for lineages that should be considered for comparison of DNA to the Tonoloways Settlement COMBS-COOMBS for furthering the ancestry.

Boone Co, IN descendants should examine a potential connection with COMBS-COOMBS of Nelson Co, KY area due to migration of John, Samuel and Edward COMBS-COOMBS assoc’d with the Tonoloways. The migration patterns of their descendants should also be taken into account.

Due to the mutation of Denman COMBS of Newton Co, IN and William COMBS of Perry Co, OH and VA, their lineages and potential relatedness need to be studied further since they are distinct from all other person’s tested and imply a unique relationship. They probably come from a specific branch of Joseph COOMBE. This is especially important since the DNA of the descendants of Joseph COOMBE does not appear to mutate quickly.

The John Joseph COMBS line for Hampshire Co, VA has a unique mutation none of the other lines do which may be the clue to the branch from which this line descends.

Posted: 6 Jun 2005
Updated 26 Jan 2009

Andrew COMBS Lineage Snapshot Tonoloways > Loudoun Co, VA Combs42 of 43 Markers Agree
John COMBS Lineage Snapshot Tonoloways > Fayette Co, PA > Nelson Co, KY Combs43 of 43 Markers Agree
Edward COOMBS Lineage Snapshot Tonoloways > Nelson Co, KY Combs42 of 43 Markers Agree
Andrew COMBS Lineage Snapshot Frederick Co, VA Combs43 of 43 Markers Agree
Samuel COOMBS Lineage Snapshot Tonoloways > Loudoun Co, VA > Nelson Co, KY Combs43 of 43 Markers Agree
Denman COMBS Lineage Snapshot Boone Co, IN42 of 43 Markers Agree
John Newton COMBS Lineage Snapshot Boone Co, IN43 of 43 Markers Agree
William Combs Lineage Snapshot VA and Perry Co, OH42 of 43 markers agree
Harvey D. Coombes Lineage Snapshot TX and Douglas & Ferry Co’s WA, possibly IA43 of 43 markers agree
John Joseph Combs Lineage Snapshot Hampshire Co, VA42 of 43 markers agree
LINEAGE GENETIC PROFILE ESTABLISHEDMATCHEXTENT OF MATCH*COMMENTS
AMERICA
Stafford County, Virginia Colony
Joseph COMBS Descendants CONCLUSION:

There are three branches of COMBS that have been distinguished by DNA findings -- Joseph, Archdale and William. This improves on the research in Josiah Combs´ work which assumes William Combs RW is the son of Mason Combs Sr. Chapters IV & XX.

NEXT RESEARCH STEP:

Joseph Combs Two lines are proven directly to the progenitor Joseph, father of John & Joseph believed to marry Bullitt sisters. These lines need to connect further back likely in the British Isles. The Arkansas line needs further study to match up, particularly in Clark Co, KY. The Loudoun Co, VA line could benefit from maternal DNA testing to determine the connection further.

The lineage of William COMBS and Sitha Stacy needs DNA testing to validate the assumption that this is the correct William of Mason COMBS Sr. These lines need to be compared to other branches of early Virginia and surrounding colonies. Eventually, these will need comparison with the British Isles COMBS. The Archdale COMBS line may need further comparison with Continental Europe COMBS.
See Special Study: STAFFORD COUNTY, VIRGINIA (under construction) Lineage

Posted: 1 July 2005
Updated 28 Jan 2009

John Combs m: Seth Bullitt f/o Cuthbert Combs Lineage Snapshot Stafford County Cuthbert COMBS & Sarah Evans42 of 43 Markers Agree
John Combs m: Seth Bullitt f/o Benjamin Combs Lineage Snapshot Stafford County Cuthbert COMBS & Sarah Evans42 of 43 Markers Agree
Joseph Combs m: Mary McMakin f/o Alexander Combs m: Dicey Perry Lineage Snapshot Stafford County Joseph Combs I42 of 43 Markers Agree
John Combs m: Kesiah Jackson Lineage Snapshot Jackson Co, AR41 of 43 Markers Agree
Archdale COMBE>John COMBE Descendants
Mason Combs, Sr m: Sarah f/o Mason Combs, Jr. Lineage Snapshot Stafford County Mason Combs, Jr.43 of 43 Markers Agree

Mason Combs, Sr m: Sarah f/o John COMBS m Nancy Harding Lineage Snapshot Jeremiah “Long Jerry” Combs42 of 43 Markers Agree
Mason Combs, Sr m: Sarah f/o John COMBS m Nancy Harding Lineage Snapshot John COMBS & Nancy HARDING41 of 43 Markers Agree

Mason Combs, Sr m: Sarah f/o John COMBS m Nancy Harding Lineage Snapshot41 of 43 Markers Agree
William COMBS RW Descendants
William Combs m: Sarah Million Lineage Snapshot Prince William/Stafford Co, VA William Combs, Sr.41 of 43 markers Agree
William Combs m: Sarah Million Prince William/Stafford Co, VA William Combs, Sr.41 of 43 markers Agree
LINEAGE GENETIC PROFILE ESTABLISHEDMATCHEXTENT OF MATCH*COMMENTS
AMERICA
St. Mary’s Co, MD; Jefferson Co, TN; Wilkes & Cobb Cos, GA
Common Ancestor TBD CONCLUSION:

Share the same ancestry; Convergence needs to be determined. This ancestry appears to tie directly to COMBS from Maryland. This does not preclude the need to study Virginia COMBS, particularly the Westmoreland Co, VA Philip COMBS.

NEXT RESEARCH STEP:

Further examination is underway to study the COMBS of St. Mary’s County, MD, particularly the descendants of Enoch COMBS. A comparison with the descendants of Enoch COMBS, sometimes described as the Catholic branch who went to the Bardstown KY area, is needed to validate this branch is of Enoch COMBS in the absence of a paper trail or better information on the participant from Leonardtown. An explanation for the differences and application of the 464 series is underway.

Posted: 3 Nov 2005
Updated 06 Apr 2007

Unknown Ancestor of Leonardtown, St. Mary’s Co, MD COMBS
PRIVATE PARTICIPANT
This line connects in the 1800s to the St. Mary’s Co, MD group.
41 of 43 markers Agree except for 464 b thru f series.
Unknown Ancestor of Leonardtown, St. Mary’s Co, MD COMBS
PRIVATE PARTICIPANT
This line connects in the 1800s to the St. Mary’s Co, MD group.
John Combs m: Sarah Mabry Lineage Snapshot Jefferson Co, TN Combs41 of 43 Markers Agree
John Combs m: Millie Lineage Snapshot Wilkes & Cobb Co’s. GA
LINEAGE GENETIC PROFILE ESTABLISHEDMATCHEXTENT OF MATCH*COMMENTS
AMERICA
Vigo Co, IN
Elihu COMBS Descendants CONCLUSION:

This line which includes a Biram COMBS is unrelated to the Biram COMBS line in Perry Co, KY assuming the research indicates the Biram of Perry Co, KY is a descendant of Archdale COMBE of Old Rappahannock Co, VA and England.

NEXT RESEARCH STEP:

Earlier COMBS of Vigo Co, IN, of a William and a Biram, should be studied to identify males who could test for those lines to compare for furthering the ancestry of Elihu COMBS.

Posted: 06 Apr 2007

Ashley COMBS 40 of 43 markers Agree.
Roe COMBS
LINEAGE GENETIC PROFILE ESTABLISHEDMATCHEXTENT OF MATCH*COMMENTS
AMERICA
Middlesex Co, NJ; Clay Co, IN; Sullivan Co, TN Izard Co. AK, New Brunsiwck, Canada
Common Ancestor TBD CONCLUSION:

This group clearly has faster mutating amino acids than our experience with other groups. The geographic distribution includes Arkansas, Tennessee, Canada, and Indiana. The use of Johnathan and Jonathan is a clear clue here as to relatedness. NEXT RESEARCH STEP:

A distinct finding here is a direct match by the DNA for Dennis Combes branch of this line. Finding where and when mutations occur will help determine the relationships and ferret out the distinct branches of this group. Some mutations are clearly showing there is relatedness among some of the persons tested. This should be used as a directional clue for further family history study.

The connection of Dennis Combes branch should be pursued to see what are the potential links into other groups in New Jersey.

Identifying the possible openings for connecting the later branch of Samuel Stockwell COMBS with the earlier male lines of the Middlesex Co, NJ group should be done. Also, a close look at records like tax lists that could show a group dropping out at a specific time (annually) may help the later branch connect. As to the TN line with 3 differences, there needs to be an effort to test other branches that converge as far back as possible to rule in or out a mutation that stands out as being different than all the other lines being compared. If this mutation and what generation it occurred can be determined, the ties from TN to NJ can be solidified.

Posted: 06 Apr 2007
Updated 31 Mar 2009

Dennis COMBES Snapshot Middlesex, New Jersey & York, New Brunswick Canada43 of 43 Markers Agree
Jonathan COMBS (mid 1700s-?) Snapshot Middlesex Co, NJ
Thomas COMBS (Abt 1675-1723) Snapshot Monmouth Co, NJ
Samuel Stockwell COMBS Snapshot Posey Twp. Clay Co, IN
Note: These share the same single mutation on the same numbered marker.
40 of 43 markers agree
Robert COMBS (1827-1902) Snapshot VA > KY- Izard Co, AR
Note: This line shares the same single mutation of the group above, however, has 3 additional mutations.
39 of 43 markers agree
William COMBS (1831-1911) Snapshot Sullivan Co, TN
NOTE: Shares a mutation with the next group below.
42 of 43 markers agree
Johnathan COMBS (1830s-?) Snapshot Sullivan Co?, TN
Jonathan COMBS (c1775-1850+) Snapshot PA? Sullivan Co, TN
NOTE: These two share the same mutation with William COMBS above, however each has an additional unique mutation.
41 of 43 markers agree
Capt John COMBS Snapshot Monmouth Co, NJ
NOTE: All three mutations are distinct from any others in this group thusfar.
40 of 43 markers agree
LINEAGE GENETIC PROFILE ESTABLISHEDMATCHEXTENT OF MATCH*COMMENTS
AMERICA
New Meadows, ME Part of Annexed Territory of MA
Anthony COOMBS Descendants CONCLUSION:

The lineage genetic profile for Anthony COOMBS will be the key to determining the ancestry of Anthony in the UK or Continental Europe. The comparison of these two lineages along with another in the Sorenson Molecular Genealogy Foundation solidifies the profile. The rd lineage clears up that DYS 458 should be an 18, not a 17, therefore making the lineage profile complete.

NEXT RESEARCH STEP:

Identify COOMBS in France and England who may fit the suggested ancestral origin localities by some researchers. Examine very closely the given name pattern in most recent records in English Archives, in particular.

Posted: 06 Apr 2007

?? of ? markers agree
?

* “Extent Matched” means the number of mutations of individuals tested from what appears to be the shared “lineage genetic profile” of their common ancestry. The “lineage genetic profile” can be dynamic and change, in some cases, with the inclusion of additional data. An individual’s genetic profile however, should remain the same.